• 1987 (Milwaukee): The Pedant and the Shuffly (proto-play)
• 1988 (Berkeley): The Fall of the Tombs of Atuan
• 1989 (Vancouver): The Reconstruction of the Fionavar Tapestry in the British Museum
• 1990 (Long Beach): Sam Spadegee and the Case of the Missing Mythcon
• 1991 (San Diego): The Sheik of Kesrith: A Documentary Epic Film with Sheets
• 1992 (Oxford): Famous Battles of Middle-earth
• 1993 (Minneapolis): A Fractured Fairy Tale: Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs -- The Real Sequel
• 1994 (Washington, D.C.): The Dance of the Farandolae
• 1995 (Berkeley): Mr. Peabody's Improbable History: Visiting the Romantic Poets
• 1996 (Boulder): The Return of the Shadow ... Puppets
• 1997 (Malibu): MTV (Mythopoeic Television) New Season Previews
• 1998 (Wheaton): Jose Chung's 'From Deep Heaven'
• 1999 (Milwaukee): Uppity Warrior Women of Middle-earth
• 2000 (Hawaii): Hawaii 5-0 Investigates the One Ring Conspiracy
• 2001 (Berkeley): Charles Williams' Inferno
• 2002 (Boulder): To Say Nothing of the Doge
• 2003 (Nashville): The Giftgiving
• 2004 (Ann Arbor): The Endless Musical
• 2005 (Birmingham): Return of the Return of the Shadow Puppets
• 2006 (Norman, OK): Untitled
• 2007 (Berkeley): Harry Trotter and the Ghastly Grocery List
• 2008 (New Britain, CT): A Connecticut Mythie in King Arthur's Court
• 2009 (Los Angeles): Here There Be ... Pirates!
• 2010 (Dallas, TX): Untitled Tim Powers-themed spoof
• 2011 (Albuquerque, NM): Monstrous Tales in the Land of Enchantment
• 2012 (Berkeley, CA): When Myths Collide
• 2013 (East Lansing, MI): Watership Downton Abbey
• 2014 (Norton, MA): Where Fantasy Fits
• 2015 (Colorado Springs, CO): The Bachelorette in Camelot
• 2016 (San Antonio, TX): Till We Have Races
• 2017 (Champaign-Urbana, IL): All That Glitters
• 2018 (Atlanta, GA): Untitled

Little Gems